Before paying for software to catch fraudulent clicks, look at what Google already catches for free, because it is more than most advertisers assume and it is now easier to see. Google filters clicks it judges invalid before you are billed for them, credits back spend on invalid activity it identifies after an invoice is issued, and reports both inside your account. The question worth answering is how large the problem is that remains after all of that, and whether a subscription would recover more than it costs.
What Google counts as invalid
Google's definition is broader than deliberate fraud. Its documentation on invalid activity1 (opens in a new tab) describes invalid traffic as clicks and interactions that do not come from genuine user interest, including intentionally fraudulent traffic and accidental or duplicate clicks. When Google identifies such clicks, its help page on invalid clicks2 (opens in a new tab) says it tries to filter them automatically from your reports and payments so that you are not charged.
You can see the filtered count by adding the Invalid clicks column to your campaign reports. Most advertisers have never switched it on.
The credit report most advertisers have not opened
Some invalid activity is caught only after billing. For that, Google now provides an Invalid Activity Credit Report, available in the Report Editor for Search and Performance Max campaigns. It shows credited clicks, the credited amount, and adjusted versions of your cost, clicks, conversion rate and cost per conversion with the credits subtracted. Google notes that a credit can land in the month after the click it relates to, so the figures for any single month can look slightly out of step.
The adjusted metrics are the reason to open it. An account that judges itself on cost per conversion before credits is judging itself on a number Google has partly refunded.
When protection software pays for itself
Third-party click fraud tools watch the traffic arriving at your site, flag patterns they consider suspicious, and typically push exclusions back into the ad account. Their value is limited to the problem left over after Google's filtering and credits. That gives a clean break-even test.
A tool costing a monthly fee has to prevent at least that amount of spend which was invalid, was not filtered or credited by Google, and would not have produced a customer. Expressed as a share of ad spend, the hurdle is the fee divided by the budget. Using a hypothetical $100-a-month tool to show the shape of it: on $2,000 of monthly spend the tool must recover 5% of the budget, net of Google's credits, just to break even. On $20,000 it must recover 0.5%.
That arithmetic explains who these tools suit. Large accounts with expensive clicks clear the hurdle easily if there is a real problem. Small accounts with modest click costs rarely do, because the residual fraud would have to be very large relative to spend. Industry estimates of how much traffic is fraudulent mostly come from companies that sell the fix, which is a reason to measure your own account rather than adopt their figure.
What usually gets called fraud
In practice, many of the clicks owners call fraud are real clicks that the campaign settings invited. Google's own click quality investigation form3 (opens in a new tab) lists poor-quality form submissions and clicks from outside your location targeting alongside invalid clicks, which says something about how often the three are confused.
Four checks resolve most of it. Read the search terms report for queries that have nothing to do with what you sell, since loosely matched keywords produce a great deal of traffic that looks pointless and is in fact simply irrelevant. Review where display and Performance Max ads have appeared, because apps and low-quality sites can produce accidental taps in volume. Check whether ads run on Google's search partner network and whether that traffic converts at all. And check your location settings: Google can be set to reach people who have shown interest in your area as well as people who are physically in it, which for a local service business often means paying for clicks from people who will never be customers.
Each of those has a setting that fixes it, and none needs a subscription.
When fraud is the more likely explanation
Deliberate clicking is real, and some situations make it more plausible: local markets with very expensive clicks and a small number of direct competitors, such as personal injury law or emergency home services. The signs are patterns rather than a single bad week. Clicks cluster at the same times of day, from the same small area, with no calls, no form fills and very short visits, while the same campaign's other traffic behaves normally.
If you see that pattern, document it and submit it through Google's click quality form, which is the route Google provides for investigations. Exclude the IP addresses you can identify. If the problem persists after the settings above are tightened, a protection tool becomes a reasonable purchase, and you will be able to judge it against a baseline you measured yourself.
Pull ninety days first
Before deciding anything, add the Invalid clicks column, open the Invalid Activity Credit Report, and run both across the last ninety days. Then read the search terms and placement reports for the same window. Most owners who do this find that the waste they were worried about has a name and a setting, and the ones who still see an unexplained pattern now have the evidence to act on it.